Why Disaster Recovery Isn’t Enough Anymore
“While DR plans focus on getting systems back online as quickly as possible, CR must deal with active, ongoing threats, often while under legal, reputational, and financial pressure.”
The Problem: Disaster Recovery Wasn’t Built for Ransomware
Your disaster recovery (DR) plan might look great on paper. Systems mapped. Failover protocols tested. Documentation in place. Maybe you even ran a full simulation last quarter.
But here’s the hard truth: DR was never designed to handle ransomware. DR assumes a safe, stable environment. Ransomware breaches that assumption by introducing ongoing, intelligent, and evolving threats.
Cyber Incidents Are Not Natural Disasters
DR works well for unintentional events: power failures, hardware crashes, natural disasters. It assumes recovery starts from a clean slate. But cyber recovery (CR) begins in a hostile environment, often while adversaries are still monitoring or active within the system.
According to Enterprise Strategy Group:
- 68% of IT leaders say cyber incidents require different processes than traditional DR.
- 58% say different personnel and skill sets are needed.
You’re not just restoring systems. You’re navigating legal exposure, protecting forensic evidence, coordinating with law enforcement, and preventing reinfection.
DR vs. CR: Understanding the Distinction
| Feature / Concern | Disaster Recovery (DR) | Cyber Recovery (CR) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Use Case | Natural disasters, hardware failures | Ransomware, insider threats, cyberattacks |
| Assumes Safe Environment? | Yes | No |
| Key Objective | Restore availability | Restore integrity and ensure containment |
| Personnel | IT Ops, Infrastructure teams | Security, Forensics, Legal |
| Tools Used | Backup, replication, failover | Cleanroom, tamper-proof backups, SIEM |
| Time Sensitivity | High (speed-focused) | High (but integrity-verified) |
| Risks if Mishandled | Downtime | Re-infection, data loss, legal exposure |
How to Build Your Cyber Recovery Capability
A mature CR strategy isn’t just an enhanced DR plan, it’s a separate discipline requiring its own tooling, processes, and personnel. Here’s a step-by-step implementation guide:
-
Conduct a CR Capability Assessment
Start with a structured assessment of existing DR capabilities against ransomware-specific scenarios.
Key Questions:
- Can you detect and isolate malware in backup copies?
- Are recovery workflows segmented from production networks?
- Are forensic logs preserved during recovery?
- Do key personnel understand CR roles and chain of custody?
Use NIST 800-184 and CIS Controls as baselines.
-
Design an Isolated Cleanroom Architecture
A cleanroom environment is a physically or virtually isolated infrastructure used to inspect, rebuild, and verify systems before reintroducing them to production.
Design Principles:
- Fully segregated network with zero trust policy
- No inbound/outbound connectivity to production
- Logging, monitoring, and forensic capture enabled
- Manual approval steps for rehydration of data and services
-
Build the Right CR Team
Cyber recovery is not just a technical challenge. It requires cross-functional alignment:
Roles to Include:
- Incident Response Lead
- Digital Forensics Analyst
- Backup and Storage Lead
- Legal Counsel
- Compliance Officer
- Communications Director
Each role should have defined runbooks, and be included in tabletop exercises.
-
Establish Testing and Validation Procedures
Testing CR readiness must go beyond standard DR failover testing.
What to Include:
- Simulated ransomware attacks
- Cleanroom restore drills
- Chain of custody workflows
- Evidence collection and preservation
- Recovery time and integrity benchmarks
Adopt red team/blue team simulations with clear success/failure metrics.
-
Align to Frameworks and Regulations
Demonstrating cyber recovery maturity often ties directly to regulatory expectations:
| Regulation / Framework | Relevance to CR |
|---|---|
| NIST 800-184 | Guide to Cybersecurity Event Recovery |
| CIS Controls v8 | Emphasises asset protection and response |
| MITRE ATT&CK | Maps adversary behaviour for CR planning |
| DORA (EU Financial Sector) | Requires resilience & recovery proof |
| HIPAA / GDPR | Mandates breach recovery accountability |
Cyber Recovery Maturity Model
Use this model to evaluate where your organisation stands today, and set goals for advancement.
| Maturity Level | Description |
|---|---|
| Level 1: Ad Hoc | No CR plan; traditional DR only. No ransomware-specific testing or cleanroom capability. |
| Level 2: Reactive | Some response steps defined; partial team involvement; no isolation enforcement. |
| Level 3: Defined | CR plan documented. Cleanroom architecture in place. Initial testing done. |
| Level 4: Integrated | Fully staffed CR team. Workflows rehearsed. Metrics tracked. Aligned with legal/compliance. |
| Level 5: Optimised | Continuous improvement model. Regular adversary simulation. CR integrated into org resilience. |
Cost of Inaction: Quantifying the Risk
Organisations that rely solely on DR plans risk serious fallout. Use this basic cost model:
Estimated Business Impact = (Downtime Hours x Hourly Revenue Impact) + Compliance Fines + Reputation Damage Multiplier
Example: A mid-sized SaaS company loses €100,000/hr in revenue, suffers 24 hours of ransomware downtime, and faces €250,000 in legal and customer notification costs. Total loss exceeds €2.6 million.
Conclusion: Cyber Recovery as a Strategic Imperative
Disaster recovery alone is no longer sufficient. As cyber threats evolve in sophistication, organisations must evolve their recovery strategies.
A robust CR program:
- Reduces risk of reinfection
- Protects against compliance penalties
- Enhances trust with stakeholders
- Speeds full business restoration
The shift to cyber recovery isn’t optional. It’s foundational.
Now is the time to act.
Book a Cyber Recovery Strategy Session
Identify your organisation’s vulnerabilities before attackers do.
- CR capability audit
- Cleanroom design workshop
- Role-based readiness review
Contact the SureLogik team today.
Trusted by Commvault for 20+ years to deliver cyber recovery excellence.